‘So Much Love’ by Rebecca Rosenblum

somuchloveReviewed by Dana Hansen

To read Toronto writer Rebecca Rosenblum’s first novel, recently nominated for the 2017 Amazon.ca First Novel Award, as mainly a thriller about the mysterious disappearance of two people from their small Ontario town, is to place too much emphasis on the surface of this quietly brilliant novel, overlooking its deeper, perhaps less conspicuous themes and implications.

It is true that the story of Catherine Reindeer’s abduction and captivity in the company of high school student Donny Zimmerman is critical to the framework of So Much Love. Without Catherine and her ordeal at the centre of the story providing a point of connection, the novel operates as essentially a collection of discrete vignettes of the lives of minor, though fascinating and well-drawn, characters. The “worst thing to ever happen to Catherine,” tragic and horrifying to be sure, serves as the novel’s through line. It keeps the story’s momentum going while allowing Rosenblum to digressively explore, through her peripheral characters and their ties to Catherine, the intricacies of intimate relationships, the ways in which love both saves and destroys, and the capacity of art to provide light in dark times.

Of all the narratives connected to Catherine, though, it is the story of young poet Julianna Ohlin that stands out in the novel for its haunting effect and for what we might read into its inclusion. Early in So Much Love we learn that Catherine, at twenty-seven years old, is a university student taking a Canadian poetry class with a Professor Altaris. Prior to her disappearance, she is studying the posthumous publications of Ohlin, a former resident of Catherine’s hometown of Iria and a one-time student of the same university Catherine attends. Ohlin, full of creative promise, died – likely at the hands of a violent husband – in the mid-1990s, before she had the chance to do “the work she was going to do.”

Catherine is struck by the similarities between her life and Ohlin’s: “this poet, Julianna Ohlin, seems to have had a life a lot like Catherine’s, at least up until now. They both waitress, they were both young when they hooked up with their partners, they both liked school and books.” Ohlin “seems like she could be Catherine in another life.” And this may be the point of this seemingly parallel storyline: Ohlin, like Catherine, was a young woman in pursuit of understanding her place in the world, buoyed up by her love of writing poetry – “a feeling of plenty even when she was broke” – and the promise of her first published book. And also like Catherine, Ohlin’s progress toward her future and “the work that was still to come” was interrupted by male violence: “The book, the job, the cat – there were too many things she was doing lately that he didn’t control, and he wanted this victory, or had wanted it in the moment. He wanted her to fall, but didn’t want to admit he made it happen, not even to himself. He hated her. They loved each other.”

Unlike Catherine, though, Ohlin did not survive that violence, her poetry and voice permanently muted. Catherine’s escape from her captor gives her the second chance that Ohlin did not have.

By juxtaposing the lives and tragedies of Julianna Ohlin and Catherine Reindeer, Rosenblum emphasizes the role that art and knowledge play in enriching and even sustaining life. In the darkness of her captor’s basement prison, in the face of pain and terrible abuse, Catherine recalls Ohlin’s poems, reciting them over and over for comfort to herself and Donny, so much so “that they started to feel like prayers.” In the most extraordinary and horrific of circumstances, Ohlin’s focus on the everyday details of life in her poems becomes a kind of balm. “I realized that everything ordinary was what I loved,” Catherine says. “And so I tried to escape in my mind back to those ordinary things by remembering her poems.”

And it is through Catherine’s love of books and reading, a constant in her much-altered life, that she may, we’re led to believe by the novel’s end, be able to move forward in the aftermath of her suffering. With a subtle touch, Rosenblum uses the familiar symbolism of darkness and light in So Much Love, contrasting the gloomy hopelessness of the basement with references to the light Catherine sees when she returns to her university, the light of knowledge: “It’s nearly full dark now but the bright windows of the library stay where they’ve always been, and behind the light, I can see all the books I haven’t yet read.”

So Much Love, a masterfully complex and beautiful novel, is about so many things, but for this reader it is principally about the promise of a young woman reclaiming her voice and her right to be on her way, to do what she loves, and to be the person she wishes to become.

McClelland & Stewart | 304 pages | $24.95 | paper | ISBN# 9780771072437

Be Sociable, Share!


  • Survey Time: Tell us what you think! (And maybe win some books!)

    Perhaps you are a dedicated reader of the Winnipeg Review who is itching to provide your feedback to help us improve. (We really hope so!) Perhaps you love the possibility of winning copies of the best of Canada’s literary fiction and having them shipped to your door. Either way, we’ve got you covered! MORE >

  • Show Me Your Worm

    By Jane Eaton Hamilton

    I wish I had something exciting to tell beginning writers about my writing life, or an opinion about recent events to shout, but if you set an apple on a countertop and walk away, returning seven hours later to find it undisturbed, you’ll see the excitement of my life. Until you chop it and you find the worm, twining its brown head from its secret pulp burrow, tasting the change in its plans. MORE >


  • 'Loving a Stranger': An Interview with Barbara Gowdy

    Barbara GowdyBy Rudrapriya Rathore

    Internationally acclaimed author Barbara Gowdy’s newest novel, Little Sister, is a remarkable look at the intricacies of emotional lives and the spectre of the past. When a series of thunderstorms hits Toronto one summer, Rose Bowan finds herself inexplicably transported into the body and consciousness of another woman for short bursts of time. MORE >

New Work

  • 'What to Call You'

    By Casey Plett

    When I lived in Portland, I met this tiny trans woman with razor-straight chestnut bangs and she told me a story. MORE >


  • 'Grey Water'

    By Carleigh Baker

    The ocean is still this morning. I can’t even tell you what a relief that is. Those waves have been pounding away for days, maybe weeks, who the hell knows? Drowning out every thought, every sound. MORE >

Book Reviews

  • ‘Next Year, For Sure’ by Zoey Leigh Peterson

    nextyearReviewed by Liz Harmer

    A synopsis can tell you most of what you already know about Next Year, For Sure, Zoey Leigh Peterson’s debut novel: Chris and Kathryn have been together happily for nine years when they decide to try opening up the relationship. He has a habit of falling in love and a “high cuddle drive,” while “nothing invigorates Kathryn like a good crush.” This good crush comes along in the form of Emily, an outgoing odd-jobber who lives in a house full of eccentrics. MORE >

  • ‘Hope Has Two Daughters’ by Monia Mazigh

    hopetwoReviewed by Seyward Goodhand

    Some remarkable novels translated into English in the last few years have at their core a passionate platonic relationship between two women. MORE >

  • ‘Barrelling Forward’ by Eva Crocker

    barrellingReviewed by Charlene Van Buekenhout

    Reading the short stories in Barrelling Forward by emerging writer Eva Crocker was like an exercise in my body’s capacity for taking in anxiety by proxy. Crocker’s ability to infuse each story with cinematic detail creates suspense out of ordinary situations. MORE >

  • ‘Bad Endings’ by Carleigh Baker

    Bad EndingsReviewed by Casey Plett

    Short story collections are kind of my personal bread-and-butter reads. I like them like I figure my dad liked Elmore Leonard. Even when I’m pretty sure I know where the book’s going, damned if I won’t enjoy getting there. MORE >

  • ‘Little Sister’ by Barbara Gowdy

    Little SisterReviewed by Rudrapriya Rathore

    Little Sister, renowned Canadian author Barbara Gowdy’s newest novel, introduces itself more effectively than I can:

    Rose Bowan, sitting in the office of the Regal Repertory Theatre, watched a rainstorm from her window and felt “a quick, exquisite sensation of her skin tightening and cooling.” Hearing the phone ring, she snatched it up. “‘Harriet here,’ she said in a croaky, tentative voice that was not Rose’s but somehow exactly hers. And the name wasn’t hers, of course, but it suited the small, kinetic person she seemed to be inside.” MORE >

  • Subscribe2